Id: arxiv/2611.11819 Url: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.11819 Tags: cs.AI, cs.LG, math.OC, stat.ML Score: 0 Title: When Should AI Overturn a Human Decision? Controversy at the 2026 World Cup and a $\sqrt{2/π}$ Solution Domain: cs.AI Source: arxiv Authors: Amir Ali Ahmadi, Parsa Alavi, Radeen Alavi Reviews: 0 Subject: cs.AI Category: research Comments: 0 Disputed: false Division: cs Mentions: 0 Discussed: 0 Published: 2026-11-09 Page: https://delphi.science/r/arxiv/2611.11819 We study how to combine a human binary call (a referee's offside or onside decision) with an AI numerical measurement (VAR's estimate of an attacker's position relative to the offside line). We derive an explicit maximum-likelihood rule that determines when the referee's call should stand and when a conflicting VAR measurement should overturn it. Our model treats the true offside margin as fixed and unknown and assumes independent additive Gaussian errors in the human's perception and the AI measurement. When both errors have zero means and known standard deviations $σ_H$ and $σ_{AI}$,…